If the mind controls the brain and not the other way around as Dr Leaf suggests, why do anti-depressant medications correct depression or anxiety disorders? Offering a 21 day brain and thought detox is dangerous! As youve gathered, Dr Leaf has some pretty grandiose delusions, and she does have a tendency to repackage the evidence-based and peer-reviewed theories of real academics and scientists, reinterpreting them through her own pseudoscientific lens and promoting the final Frankenstein-esque theory as her own. You may or may not have read my final two paragraphs from the third post, in which I acknowledged that I may have misunderstood where she was coming from, but that I would welcome her response. 26. I dont know of anyone who would disagree with that regardless of their beliefs or religion. EVIDENCE CONTRADICTING DR LEAF Influence Of Thought On Health Dr Leaf has categorically stated that 75 to 98% of all illnesses are the result of our thought life on Holly Wagner? You will also be able to rethink your reaction to the information, evaluating how the thought you are working on is changing, and then reconceptualizing it by looking for patterns and triggers (little by little, day by day). He doesnt inflict himself on you like dad does, but neither one has a conscience. A robust discussion provides the information required for people to make an informed choice. Just because they are sharing something new theyve learned or just because they mention the name of someone who is involved in the charismatic movement, doesnt make them dangerous. It was advertised as an event that would help us learn to detox the brain. You say, Being a leader doesnt require her to be flawless so we must give her and all leaders grace and room for error. . This isnt a new concept, even the CDC knows it. Answering Shapiro et al.s (2006) seminal call for a measurement that assesses not only mindfulness but also its necessary mediators self-regulation, resilience, reconceptualization, and exposure the Leaf Mind Management Tool was created. Depression-related cognitions: antecedent or consequence?. Im not sure if there is a similar study in the US, but the latest Australian data suggests that all psychological illness only counts for 8% of visits to Australian primary care physicians [5]. No expert would rely on references that are nearly 40 years old, especially in the field of genetics. PROSTATE There are only two risk factors for prostate cancer, familial aggregation and ethnic origin. Thus water is contaminated, etc etc. lol). One of the many studies that have come out of this research, done by the Buck Institute for Research on Aging, showed dramatic improvement in patients diagnosed with My micronutrient levels were all well above average with the exception of a slight deficiency in biotin. Another clue to her inability to think coherently was that she said the mind is a gravity field that surrounds us. In this podcast (episode #476) and blog, I talk about how to improve your relationship, develop sexual intimacy, and increase your health and longevity through compromise. Thank you for your research and information. Prevention of type 2 diabetes mellitus by changes in lifestyle among subjects with impaired glucose tolerance. 1101 N Battlefield Blvd I went to my gynecologist for routine bloodwork because I was feeling exhausted and anxious. These results strengthen existing research that has established the same relationships. You will also learn how to detox your thoughts using her practical, detailed, and easy-to-use 21-Day Brain Detox Plan. 10. Dr Leaf even contradicts herself. 3. You can also get 20% off your order of BiOptimizers atwww.bioptimizers.com/drleafwith the coupon code: DRLEAF20) to keep my gut-brain connection in perfect health, and my evening cup of organic herbalPiquetea before bed (Get up to 20% off your organic Pique Tea order and FREE shipping atpiquetea.life/drleaf). Dr. Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist, audiologist, clinical and cognitive neuroscientist with a Masters and PhD in Communication Pathology and a BSc Logopaedics, specializing in cognitive and metacognitive neuropsychology. Its really no different to an article that I read the other day from a group of gut researchers [21] The gut is really your second brain, Greenblatt said. They did not prove that toxic thoughts cause depression. So your website is dedicated to bashing Dr. 18. I understand that you are both busy, but I believe that I have documented a number of observations, backed by recent peer-reviewed scientific literature, which directly contradict Dr Leafs teaching. Dialogues Clin Neurosci, 2011. You may be right about American Christians. Key findings from the 2021 State of the U.S. Reflect/analyze: ask, answer, discuss. I had a two for one deal and also had the other book, The Perfect You., I was excited to read this as when I flicked through I saw Howard Gardners theory made up most of it and Im an avid advocate and admirer not to mention classroom educator and promoter of the NINE theories of Multiple Intelligience. Dr Leaf may be currently working on some research, and if she is, great. I think its fair to say that while Dr Leaf draws her conclusions from some scientific documents, there is more than enough research that contradicts her statements and opinions. This about the fact she makes more money than you do and she has a bigger following and is more famous, right? Why is it that we allow medical doctors (Christians and non Christians) to pump us full of drugs and we feel ok about that, but if a doctor who proclaims to be a Christian offers an alternative way based on the power of the Holy Spirit that indwells us, we become afraid that its new age or heretical. I understand that you may feel that Dr Leaf has helped you. I have only listed a small fraction, and only on some of the points she raised. As an aside, how do you factor in or out the general agreement that the things which men think are wise are plain foolishness; that spiritual things are not known by mind power?. However, in order to be true, this fact must be consistent across the whole of humanity. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. 91(5): 823-38. Mol Psychiatry, 2012. We retested and the same thing came back. Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist with a Masters and PhD in Communication Pathology and a BSc Logopaedics, specializing in cognitive and Teachers were provided with webinars covering the rationale behind and 5-step process of the NeurocycleTM, a tool for mental health detoxing and management. Dr Leaf did her PhD in 1998. Ive added the link to here: https://cedwardpitt.com/2015/07/22/dr-caroline-leaf-still-contradicted-by-the-latest-evidence-scripture-and-herself/. The Bible says to speak the truth in love, not engage in naive conformity. Can you clarify which of Dr Leafs peer-reviewed articles have definitively shown the academic improvement in the cohort of 100,000 students, as you and your referee have stated? Her claim that she could put mind over matter thoughts out there to keep her son safe and keep in contact with him is very new age, and fits in with other messages that she has previously given (at the church of TD Jakes, no less) ~ https://cedwardpitt.com/2016/10/19/the-secret-teaching-of-dr-caroline-leaf/. Pingback: the truth about anxiety - ryan's blog. See that four years after you published your letter to Carolines husband, the same letter and same issues are being batted about. I am very grateful with Dr. Caroline Leaf for the opportunity that she gives mer. I know whats right. Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist with a Masters and Ph.D. in Communication Pathology, and a BSc in Logopaedics from the University of Cape Town and the University of Pretoria in South Africa. This was confirmed in the psychosocial assessments conducted alongside the QEEG tests, which revealed a corresponding improvement in decreased toxic thoughts, isolation, and overall LMM score as well as increased autonomy, awareness, empowerment, life satisfaction, and ability to manage life obstacles. Dr Leaf holds a 20-year old PhD as a sub-specialist speech pathologist. Caroline Leaf has spent the last 30 years researching the mind-brain connection, nature of mental health and formation of memory. In writing my book which critiqued Dr Leafs work, I listed 300 separate citations, and every quote of Dr Leafs was backed up by the book and page number. The purpose of this step is straightforward: to gather awareness of and embrace what you are hearing, reading, and experiencing, and to get information into the brain. Jonathon Cahn I dont know him, but a quick search of the web suggests that hes making a lot of outlandish claims. 12. WebDr Caroline Leaf | SpiritMindBody Connection NEW!!! 6. When? And let us be open to Pitts questions- valid and in need of answers. Dr Pitt..Ive spent the past few hours going through your material about Dr. Caroline Leaf. Construct validity with blood measures also revealed significant relationships between the toxic stress and anxiety subscale and homocysteine levels and DHEA/cortisol ratios. 58 Suppl 2: S33-41. I too, am always very skeptical and I shy away from prosperity based theology however I feel this is much different. Critical thinking is needed, to filter out godlessness. 58(4): 371-7. If the mind controls the brain and not the other way around as Dr Leaf suggests, why do some people with acquired brain injuries or brain tumours develop acute personality changes or thought disorders? For instance, low gamma waves and high beta waves can be associated with ADHD and anxiety, respectively, while higher theta and alpha waves can reduce generalized anxiety disorder (Dadashi et al., 2015). I experienced severe trauma through abuse two years ago and have not felt quite myself since then. However, these experiments were done on only nine subjects, and the panic attacks were induced by cholecystokinin. Youre not the first person to jump to erroneous conclusions. I was immediately sceptical of the value of what struck me as a project for evolving new or modernised Christian doctrines, based more, or as much upon what passes for science these days, than (or as) upon any of the traditional authorities for Christian doctrine. The experimental subjects were learning how to embrace and make the anxiety and depression work for them and not against them, which is a much more sustainable approach than simply trying to numb or remove emotions and feelings completely. In her latest blog post, Dr Caroline Leaf attempted to tackle the complex topic of Alzheimer disease. As good Christians we are to continue to learn and seek the truth, love others, and build Christian Faith in our Lord and Savor Jesus Christ. A study by the American Medical Association found that stress is a factor in 75% of all illnesses and diseases that people suffer from today. She fails to reference this study. Im all in favour of free thinking. Including a download to the Neurocycle App, Neurocycle Method materials & more. The intervention was basically CBT-lite and the outcome could have been a treatment effect that would have occurred with any extra treatment provided, especially since it wasnt blinded. And I certainly dont feel she is deceptive or just in it for the money. So, be intentional about creating thinker breaks throughout your day by taking a few moments every day, or when you are feeling stressed out, to switch off and just mediate on the internal. I must admit, I havent looked in depth at any of those people, so I cant say anything in great depth about them. For more information on thinker moments and how to make them a part of your daily routine, see my book, Think, Learn, Succeed. My brother is a narcissistic sociopath A little background.. I was under the impression she was an expert in her field of neuroscience which I assumed meant brain mapping and all of the scientific Data to go along with that! How can I get my money back and complain about this foul thought?! Sid asked her if that meant we could heal our cholesterol just by using the power of our minds, and Caroline Leaf said Yes. Whether its Kenneth Copeland, Tim Keller or John MacArthuror Dr. I always try spend at least an hour in the morning building my brain by doing research and then detoxing my brain using my SWITCH app. Int J Biol Sci, 2013. 19(1): 15-24. Why or why not?. . WebDr. Its obviously not. You are essentially putting the thought on trial. This woman is truly a scam artist! When the components of CBT are considered separately, the cognitive component of cognitive behavioural therapy isnt that powerful. Oh well. Im not looking for you to respond, but I am looking for you to do some soul searching and ask yourself, why do I disagree with this woman so much? She repeated the same statement in her most recent book so it is something she is confident in. Im watching a YT of her right now. It is overwhelming listening to Dr. The data collection protocol begins with an email invitation, and non-responders are contacted up to three times by email reminders spaced by 5-7 days each. Im always suspicious of anyone who claims someone is a heretic and I figured I read about what you had to say. Their mindfulness development and mental health were assessed by the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) scale before and after the program. A critical step for improving mental health is developing non-pharmacological therapies that can treat anxiety and depression effectively without reliance on pharmacological treatments and the accompanying risks for side effects and interactions. WebDr. She is just sharing her research and her personal experience to bring some hope and a natural alternative to anxiety infested, pharmaceutically dependent, malnutritioned, stressed out people. Theyre the ones who are vulnerable and theyre the ones I fight for. When it comes to our health, there are no shortcuts! 29. WebDr. Whom is misleading whom is a matter of opinion, as is ones perception of critique or criticism. WebLeaf Mind Management (LMM) Scale Validation A critical step for improving mental health is developing non-pharmacological therapies that can treat anxiety and depression effectively I get the feeling that Sid Roth doesnt have any standards when it comes to what is fact and what just sounds good. Its always interesting to hear how people react to Dr Leaf the first time they hear her. While Dr. Thank God for answering your husbands prayer and granting you all discernment. Doctors call it quackery and the church calls it new age. This challenges the brain to move into a higher gear and introspect more deeply, which is what it is designed for: deep, intellectual thinking! Can you clarify how attending the same university as Dr Christaan Barnard, or a Nobel laureate, endorses her arguments or precludes her from criticism? This will be for a grade with 90% pass, with a certificate sent to facilitator and account upgraded to facilitator when completed.